MARIBYRNONG & HOBSONS BAY
Home » Uncategorized » Paramedic defies orders in bid to save a life

Paramedic defies orders in bid to save a life

A western suburbs paramedic has revealed that he defied orders to classify an 86-year-old Altona North woman as a low priority, in the wake of the death of an elderly Williamstown woman who waited more than two hours for an ambulance.

The woman who died on January 17 was initially deemed a code 1 “lights and sirens” case, but was downgraded to a code 2.

Laverton-Point Cook paramedic Dave Hammond said that he had started keeping records as Ambulance Victoria fights moves by the state Labor opposition to obtain ambulance response times for individual branches.

“The dispatch system is increasingly frustrating paramedics’ patients who are given a lower code (code 2) and are often waiting for extended periods of time as ambulances are constantly being diverted to other, often less acute, cases,” he said.

“In one recent instance, we were dispatched to an 86-year-old female who had fallen in her backyard at night in Altona North and it was only because I requested that a ‘do not divert’ was placed on us that we were able to attend and treat her fractured hip within 20 minutes.”

Mr Hammond said during Melbourne’s recent five-day heatwave, up to six ambulances at a time were stuck at Footscray’s hospital and could not respond to other cases for more than hour.

“[On] Thursday and Friday during the heatwave multiple crews from the western suburbs, I believe at one point, five to six, were ramped at Western Hospital, Footscray, for over an hour, making them unable to respond to any cases.

“Crews from the local area are constantly being sent out of the area to attend cases in other parts of Melbourne, meaning that often ambulances from large distances away are required to attend cases within the Hobsons Bay area.”

He said that on January 18, Hobsons Bay was left with only one paramedic, who was not equipped to transport patients.

“When clearing a case in Williamstown, we were the closest available ambulance to attend a case in Northcote, meaning the entire Hobsons Bay area only had one single responder MICA paramedic – who is unable to transport patients – to cover it.”

An Ambulance Victoria spokesman would not comment on individual cases but said that the death of the Williamstown woman would be reviewed.

He disputed claims that ambulances could not cope during the heatwave.

“During this high demand, we focused ambulances on the sickest patients based on the information provided at the time of call.

“Where delays occurred, we called patients back to check on their welfare and condition and upgraded our responses where that had changed.”

Digital Editions


  • Severe thunderstorm warning issued

    Severe thunderstorm warning issued

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 253047 A severe thuderstorm warning and shelter indoors now alert has been issued for suburbs around Melbourne’s north-west. Residents…

More News

  • Car theft syndicate bust

    Car theft syndicate bust

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 245950 A car theft syndicate has been busted after police charged its alleged ringleaders and recovered stolen vehicles and key reprogramming devices amid high…

  • Footscray fish icon dies

    Footscray fish icon dies

    Footscray’s Con Goulas has been remembered as a giant of Melbourne’s seafood industry and the Greek community following his death last week aged 91. The founder of Conway Fish Trading,…

  • ’Shame’ as security trial extended

    ’Shame’ as security trial extended

    Security guards will continue to patrol the Footscray CBD until June after Maribyrnong council voted in favour of extending the controversial program at its meeting on 17 February. Cries of…

  • Sports into grand final

    Sports into grand final

    Altona Sports has ticked off its first goal of earning promotion and will now go for glory in the Bowls Victoria weekend pennant, division 4, section 1 competition. Altona Sports…

  • Right royal progress

    Right royal progress

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 432421 Williamstown amateur historian Barb McNeill is Star Weekly’s history columnist. This week she recounts a drama-filled visit to Australia by Prince Alfred, the…

  • Ballan Autumn Festival’s landmark event

    Ballan Autumn Festival’s landmark event

    Ballan’s favourite community festival is set to return for its 50th annual event on Sunday 15 March, celebrating local culture, creativity, and community. The Ballan Autumn Festival is one of…

  • Rams to go again

    Rams to go again

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 532910 Newport Rams are hoping to be better for the run after a nervous start to the Baseball Victoria summer league women’s premier 1…

  • Eskimo Joe to headline west festival

    Eskimo Joe to headline west festival

    Australia’s beloved alt-rock power trio Eskimo Joe are sure to have audiences up on their feet when they headline the Lincoln Park Twilight Festival. Held on Saturday 28 February at…

  • Inquiry into anti-LGBTIQA+ hate crimes

    Inquiry into anti-LGBTIQA+ hate crimes

    The Victorian Parliament’s Legal and Social Issues Committee is moving forward with an inquiry into anti-LGBTIQA+ hate crimes. The investigation is designed to analyse the frequency of targeted attacks, examine…

  • Festival for all abilities

    Festival for all abilities

    Ability Fest is returning to Melbourne on 11 April, 2026, with a new focus on industrial venue accessibility at The Timber Yard in Port Melbourne. The event marks a shift…