This story was originally published on 16 July 2025. Star Weekly is sharing it again for you to enjoy.
A former Hobsons Bay mayor and long-time councillor has expressed alarm at the possible sale of the Williamstown Mechanics Institute.
Selling the historic building on Electra Street was one of a number of options included in an updated masterplan that was passed at a meeting of Hobsons Bay council on July 1.
Built in 1860, the Williamstown Mechanics Institute has been closed since 2018 and requires significant repairs, including a new floor.
While the sale of the building was one of six future options included in the updated masterplan, along with exploring private partnerships, minimal, moderate and full restoration or leaving it as is, former Hobsons Bay mayor Peter Hemphill said it shouldn’t have even been considered.
“I was horrified that that was even an option,” said Mr Hemphill, whose 25-year stint on Hobsons Bay council, including three terms as mayor, ended last year.
“No one ever raised it with me that we would ever consider selling it and I would’ve recoiled at that if someone did.”
Mr Hemphill said he had no problem with council exploring various options for the building, but not a sale.
“Williamstown’s heritage should not be up for sale, particularly for public buildings. I’ve always maintained that we have to preserve Williamstown’s heritage because it is a unique part of Melbourne.”
Mr Hemphill’s views were backed up by the Williamstown Historical Society who said in a Facebook post that it was “horrified” to see the sale option included.
Those concerns were echoed by sitting councillor’s when the update was presented at the July 1 meeting.
“I hope that’s not the option that we choose,” said Cr Lisa Bentley of the possible sale.
Cr Michael Disbury also expressed opposition to selling the institute and said the most obvious solution – relaying the floor – hadn’t been included in the masterplan.
Cr Kristen Bishop said given the future of the institute building had been in limbo for so long, it was worth examining all possible outcomes.
A council spokesperson said any renewal or refurbishment works on the Williamstown Mechanics Institute would cost between $10-$15 million and given that level of investment, it was prudent to examine all options, including a possible sale.
“ It is anticipated that council will consider the outcomes of this work in early 2026,” the spokesperson said.
